The Federal High Court in Abuja has canceled Tukur Ribadu's selection as the African Democratic Congress (ADC) governorship candidate for Adamawa State. The court has ordered the Independent National Electoral Commission (INEC) to recognize Omar Suleiman as the party's candidate instead.
Judge Obiora Egwuatu ruled on Friday that the ADC should send Mr Suleiman's details to INEC for publication as the official governorship candidate. He also instructed the commission not to recognize or publish Mr Ribadu's name as the party's candidate.
The court also barred Mr Ribadu from presenting himself as the ADC governorship candidate for Adamawa State.
This ruling came after a lawsuit followed the party's decision to replace Mr Suleiman, who won the governorship primary, with Mr Ribadu. Mr Suleiman challenged the change, claiming he won the primary and the party had no legal right to replace him.
Before looking at the main issue, Judge Egwuatu reviewed preliminary objections raised by the ADC and Mr Ribadu.
The ADC asked the court to dismiss the case, calling it incompetent and an abuse of court process. Mr Ribadu also sought to have it thrown out, saying the court had no jurisdiction.
They argued that Mr Suleiman's written address went beyond the page limit set by the Federal High Court’s Election Proceedings Practice Directions. They claimed the address was 17 pages instead of the maximum 15.
But Mr Suleiman opposed this claim, saying that the extra pages did not warrant dismissing the suit.
The judge noted that the address was indeed two pages over the limit but chose not to dismiss it. He stated that doing so would not serve justice.
The ADC also claimed that the lawsuit relied on a constitutional provision that did not apply to the party. Judge Egwuatu disagreed and said he could not rule the suit as incompetent at this early stage.
The defendants further argued that the suit was filed late because Mr Suleiman did not submit it within the 14 days required for pre-election matters under the Constitution. They said he should have filed it sooner, not waiting until 6 August.
However, the judge ruled that the action was started within the time allowed by the Constitution.
The defendants also said Mr Suleiman did not use the party's internal process to resolve the issue before going to court.
The judge dismissed this argument, saying that forcing Mr Suleiman to follow the party's internal process would have made him miss the 14-day constitutional deadline. He ruled that Mr Suleiman had the right to go to court to protect his rights instead of letting the time run out.
No valid reason to replace him
Looking at the case itself, the judge considered whether Mr Ribadu had contested the primary election result through the ADC’s appeal committee and if that committee was properly set up.
Mr Suleiman argued that there was no proper appeal committee and no proof that Mr Ribadu had raised any challenge with such a committee.
The ADC and Mr Ribadu insisted that an appeal was made and that the committee reviewed the result before the party's National Working Committee accepted its report.
They argued that the appeal committee sent its report to the National Working Committee, which reviewed it and made a resolution on 29 May.
Mr Ribadu also said his name was presented to INEC after the party decided to review the disputed result.
The judge looked at documents from a previous case involving another candidate, which Mr Suleiman used to support his argument. The documents included filings by the ADC and statements from party officials who supervised the primary election.
He pointed out that the party’s documents from the earlier case did not show that Mr Ribadu petitioned the appeal committee or that the committee ruled on any such petition in his favor.
The judge also considered affidavits from the chairman and secretary of the ADC’s Adamawa State primary election committee. They confirmed that an appeal committee was not set up to review the governorship primary.
The judge also relied on the primary election committee’s report, which stated that no complaints had been received when it submitted its findings. The report also noted that no violence occurred at the election venue.
The court found no proof that Mr Ribadu had successfully challenged the primary result through the party’s appeal process. It upheld Mr Suleiman’s claim that he won the primary and that the party had no valid reason to replace him.
Suleiman’s win and the dispute
Mr Suleiman, a former managing director of the Nigerian Ports Authority and former ambassador to the Democratic Republic of the Congo, won the ADC governorship primary in Adamawa State in May, beating Mr Ribadu.
Reports from the primary election showed that Mr Suleiman got 143,216 votes from the 21 local government areas. Mr Ribadu came second with 56,801 votes, while another candidate, Umar Uba, got 20,343 votes.
In late May, Nicholas Msheliza, the chairman of the party’s Adamawa State Governorship Primary Committee, announced the results and declared Mr Suleiman the winner.
But later, the party’s national leadership backed Mr Ribadu as its candidate, even after Mr Suleiman’s victory. This led Mr Suleiman to take the matter to court.








Drop your comment
No comments yet — be the first to drop the gist 👇