Court Confirms Suswam's Win in Benue APC Primary Election

By Chioma Eze/ 18 Nov 2026(updated 51m ago)/ 3 min read/ 22 views
Court Confirms Suswam's Win in Benue APC Primary Election
Sponsored — In Article

The Federal High Court in Abuja has declared Gabriel Suswam, a former governor of Benue State, the winner of the All Progressives Congress senatorial primary for Benue North-East. The court ordered the party to send his name to the Independent National Electoral Commission as its candidate for the 2027 general elections.

Justice Inyang Ekwo delivered the ruling on Wednesday. The case was marked FHC/ABJ/CS/1470/2026, and it was filed by Suswam against the APC, the current Senator Emmanuel Udende, and INEC.

The judge confirmed that the electoral commission's report showed Suswam won the primary on May 18, 2026, with 131,083 votes, while Udende only got 1,364 votes. He pointed out that neither the APC nor Udende provided any results to challenge the numbers from INEC.

Justice Ekwo ruled in favor of Suswam, granting the reliefs he sought in the suit. The conflict started when the APC decided to replace Suswam with Udende after its Primary Election Appeal Committee reviewed complaints from the May primaries. Despite Suswam winning the primary, the party sent Udende's name to INEC as its candidate, leading Suswam to seek legal action.

Before addressing the main issues, Justice Ekwo dismissed preliminary objections from the defendants. They argued that the court did not have jurisdiction because the case involved the internal matters of a political party. The judge ruled that anyone who took part in a party primary can go to court if they claim there was a breach of the Electoral Act, the party's constitution, or its guidelines.

He added that the Electoral Act takes precedence over a party's internal rules when assessing legal compliance. Justice Ekwo also rejected claims that Suswam did not have the standing to file the case, stating that he had the right as a candidate in the primary.

The court also dismissed the defendants' claim that the suit was time-barred, stating that their objections were not valid. On the main issue, the judge confirmed there was no disagreement that the APC held a primary election on May 18, 2026, which INEC monitored.

He noted that the commission's report submitted to the court verified that Suswam won with 131,083 votes, while Udende received 1,364 votes. The judge remarked that neither the APC nor Udende contested the validity of INEC's report or provided any alternative results.

"Therefore, the court has no reason not to act on the INEC report since its value has not been diminished. The first and second defendants did not present any other results of the election that would have shown Udende as the winner," he stated.

Justice Ekwo criticized the APC's choice to replace Suswam with Udende based on the appeal committee's report. He mentioned that the committee's report was dated May 18, 2026, the same day as the primary election. There was no proof presented that Suswam was allowed to defend himself before this decision was made.

The judge concluded that the committee's actions violated Suswam's right to a fair hearing. He stated that INEC's evidence supported Suswam's claims. The APC and Udende did not show any grounds for dismissing the primary election results.

After the judgment, Suswam's lawyer, W.E. Tingir, said the court found that Suswam's replacement was not in line with the Electoral Act of 2026, the amended 1999 Constitution, and the APC's constitution. He called the party's actions a "blatant abuse" of the laws governing electoral primaries.

Tingir said, "This is a pre-election matter where we challenged the plaintiff's substitution, which was unlawful. The court has just ruled that the substitution was unlawful and not in accordance with the provisions of the Electoral Act and the Nigerian Constitution. We could not have expected otherwise; it was blatant abuse of the Electoral Act and the Party Constitution."

Gabriel Suswam was the governor of Benue State from 2007 to 2015, winning two terms. He later represented Benue North-East in the Senate from 2019 to 2023. He joined the APC in February 2026 after leaving the Peoples Democratic Party and won the party's primary on May 18 with 131,083 votes against Udende's 1,364.

Sponsored — Mid Article
Did you enjoy this gist?
C
Chioma Eze

Founder & EIC. Lagos-based.

More Like ThisHot Gist

Drop your comment

Your email won't be shown publicly. Comments may be reviewed before posting.

No comments yet — be the first to drop the gist 👇